17 Spooky Beetlejuice Party Food Ideas

Are you looking for a way to make your Halloween party that much more exciting? Make it a Beetlejuice-themed party! The bold pinstripes and color scheme will have guests laughing with nostalgic glee. And the spooky Beetlejuice party food ideas you’ll be including are the best part! Peerspace is just the place to be if you need to create a menu or book a party venue for an awesome Halloween party.

1. Mix green Beetlejuice cocktails

Let’s start with a spooky beverage that’s far from boring: Beetlejuice cocktails! A few black and white painted glasses are the perfect pairing to this bright green cocktail. The cucamelon cocktail garnishes in the recipe we’ve shared are another nice touch your local farmer’s market might have in stock!

2. Whip up black-and-white Beetlejuice Halloween pudding shots

Beetlejuice party food ideas should depart a little from the usual Halloween orange and purple. So check out this recipe for black and white Beetlejuice pudding shots! The color scheme of these snacks is also amazing for a Nightmare Before Christmas party.

As fun as these Beetlejuice party food ideas are, don’t forget to pick a venue in advance! Halloween is a major holiday so choose a fun spot with us at Peerspace. We have some of the best party venues in the country, like this vapor wave loft in Los Angeles, CA, with a TV projector and sound system to watch Beetlejuice with your friends!

3. Decorate the perfect Beetlejuice cake

Bring all of the haunted house colors of Beetlejuice together on top of a single amazing-looking cake! Whether it’s for a Beetlejuice birthday or you’re adding the theme to a Halloween party, a cake is never out of place at the snack table. Plus it’s a great chance to get truly creative in the kitchen by adding frosting spiders, layers of black and white cake, or some frosting slime to complete the Beetlejuice cake!

4. Bake some Beetlejuice Halloween pinwheel cookies

Kooky Halloween cookies are way more about fun and laughter than creep factor. Balance out the spooky atmosphere with these Beetlejuice Halloween pinwheel cookies. The candy eyes are unique but won’t deter anyone from taking a bite! You’ve got to love those fun swirling colors as well as a festive touch to the party snack table.

Add more gothic fun to your party using our cool Wednesday Addams party ideas!

5. Chop up some severed toes in bandages

From the little almond nails to the pretzel bandages these severed toes are so much fun to make! Yet the total prep time is just 30 minutes; perfect for making a big batch of these a few hours before an awesome Beetlejuice Halloween party. Blood (ketchup) is the natural dipping sauce for these but we’d include some mustard and queso as well for variety!

6. Start with mozzarella eyeball appetizers

Beetlejuice party food ideas should be both creepy and fun. These mozzarella eyeball appetizers definitely count! From the irises to the touch of “blood” using tomato sauce, they’re super realistic. See how many of your guests dare to taste them!

7. Wrap up some mummies in a blanket

Do you mind if your food is looking back at you? Maybe your guests do but that only makes these mummies in a blanket more fun. You can use basic pigs in a blanket recipe or make your own by wrapping pizza or croissant dough around hot dogs before baking. All you need are a few candy eyes or dots of mustard to add the spook factor to your mummies in a blanket!

8. Bake some sandworm cookies

You don’t have to be a baking wizard to pull off some pinstriped sandworm cookies as a Beetlejuice party food idea! You start with regular white vanilla sugar cookie dough shaped into sandworms. Next, add some chocolate cookie dough darkened with black food coloring. Let them bake as per the recipe’s instructions and you have instant sandworms ready to cause chaos if you don’t eat them fast!

9. Decorate a batch of Beetlejuice cake pops

Cake pops are one of our favorite ways to celebrate a party theme through food. You can easily make the faces of your favorite characters with a few different colors of frosting and some candy eyes. Beetlejuice cake pops involve a lot of fine details so if you aren’t feeling adventurous, try ordering some from places like Cakepop LA instead!

10. Blend spices into a bio-exorcist green coconut curry

Ever wonder what those bio-exorcist green fluids taste like? Let your guests enjoy the spicy melange of a green coconut chicken curry! The dish naturally has just the right shade of green and it’s a savory option that can be vegetarian or vegan with the right substitutions and omissions.

11. Crown the cake with a Beetlejuice cake topper

You might already have a cake ready to go for your upcoming Beetlejuice Halloween party. Well, you can still make it a Beetlejuice-themed dessert option by picking up the right cake topper! Etsy has dozens of kinds to choose from.

12. Set your marinara dip in a saucy spider

Creepy Beetlejuice party food ideas like a saucy spider for bread dip are guaranteed to put a smile on everyone’s face! Even though they’re just breadsticks, the thick legs of this “spider” are a real conversation starter. Since the dough is pizza-based the recipe calls for marinara sauce. But you could easily substitute this for hot cheese or another dip that’s great with pizza dough.

13. Bake some gooey mozzarella web sticks

Mozzarella sticks filled with stringy webbing are just what your pizza sauce spider needs. You can dip the sticks in the same marinara sauce your saucy spider is filled with. There are many ways to make mozzarella sticks; you can bake, air fry, or oil fry them. It’s hard to mess these up but we’ve included our favorite recipe from Allrecipes to get you started.

Check out our favorite “Hocus Pocus” food ideas for more devilishly delicious party food options!

14. Rest in peace with pudding dirt cups

Lay everyone who comes to rest with a platter of pudding dirt cups! They are a no-bake dessert that takes few ingredients and even less time to make. You could even add a few layers of “dirt” using alternating Oreo cookie and chocolate pudding layers, with gummy worms, candy bones, and other hidden surprises in each layer.

15. Brew a witch’s cauldron of spinach dip

Witches and wizards are wandering about this Halloween eve! Let them enchant you with a few bites of spinach dip from a witch’s cauldron. We love the dark pumpernickel bread bowl this Beetlejuice party food idea starts with. Fill it with spooky cream-based spinach dip for an easy recipe that takes just 30 minutes to complete.

16. Slow-cook some sausage, potato, and onions for stuffed peppers

A Halloween party menu doesn’t have to offer just snacks. Let’s make a real meal using slow cooker sausage, potatoes, and onions. And then place these tasty ingredients inside orange bell peppers cut to look like jack-o-lanterns! Being a slow cooker recipe you’ll want to set aside 5-6 hours of prep time for cooking.

You should have a party venue well before you start on these stuffed peppers, however. Let Peerspace help; we have hundreds of Halloween party venues near you with projector screens, haunted decorations, and other touches for a creepy evening of fun!

17. Decorate some Beetlejuice cupcakes

Beetlejuice cupcakes look amazing if you have enough frosting colors to pull them off. Some green, purple, black, and white are must-have hues. Some paper cupcake tin liners in Beetlejuice colors can make these even easier to bake!

Beetlejuice party food ideas: conclusion

Beetlejuice party food ideas include some of the spookiest yet most laugh-inducing snacks we’ve ever found. You’ll have everyone in stitches trying your severed toes and pudding graves. We hope Peerspace has been helpful in your party planning needs; that’s what we do best, after all! Before you create your Halloween party menu, think about booking a Halloween party venue near you to set the spooky scene for your party.

Find unique event spaces for your Beetlejuice party on Peerspace